Meditation without music or voice
Can meditation without music or voice feel more pleasant when your day already seems full of impressions?
Some people don’t want to hear yet another voice during a break. Others find a familiar guide especially helpful. Leaving out sound and screen changes how you approach the practice. It is not a universal recipe for more attention.
Without music does not mean without guidance
A meditation can do without music and still be spoken. It can be completely silent or accompanied by a signal you can feel. These differences matter when you are looking for something that suits you.
Maybe you don’t want to wear headphones. Maybe waiting for the next sentence distracts you. Or you like a voice that explains at the start what you can do. None of these preferences makes your practice better or worse.
You can use Mjoll with your eyes closed. The display stays on and is dimmed to almost black; if you lock your iPhone, the session pauses. So “without looking” does not mean “with the screen turned off.”
A reduced approach leaves out certain extras. But it does not remove your surroundings: footsteps outside the door, light in the room or thoughts about your next appointment can still be there.
- With a voice
- With touch
- Without technology
Fewer channels can leave more room
Imagine a break after several video calls. You don’t want to look at another screen or follow another explanation. A haptic pulse could then be a fitting alternative. That is a plausible idea for using it, not a prediction of how you will feel afterward.
Vibration is a stimulus too. If you keep waiting for the next pulse, it can take up more attention than you would like. So reduction here means: choosing on purpose what you want to be accompanied by. It does not mean being completely free of stimuli.
What does the research say?
A review of meditation and breathing devices describes many forms of guidance, including touch, sound, light and voice. It classifies devices and their stimuli; it does not compare which channel works better. So it does not point to one best sense in general.1
For breathing exercises in general, there are indications of lower subjective stress on average. But this research does not answer whether the same exercise works better without music, without voice or with vibration. The effect of an exercise and the design of its guidance are separate questions.2
Research on broader meditation programs cannot simply be transferred to a single signal either. A good experience with a silent format is possible. It is not scientific proof that silence is superior.3
The right support can change
For comparing in everyday life, one observation is enough to start: Does the support feel clear, or does it give you something extra to deal with? You need neither a rating scale nor a personal experiment with fixed results.
You can read instructions beforehand and do without them during the session. You can keep your eyes open. You may find that today a voice gives you more orientation. One format does not have to cover every situation.
Mjoll stands for a tangible approach without sound. Whether it suits you is not decided by the number of senses involved. Maybe the right break is simply the one in which you don’t want to do anything extra right now.
Mjoll is an iPhone app for haptic meditation. See how it works
Read on
Sources
- Honinx, E.; Broes, S.; Roekaerts, B.; Huys, I.; Janssens, R. (2023). Existing Meditation and Breathing Devices for Stress Reduction and Their Incorporated Stimuli: A Systematic Literature Review and Competition Analysis. Mayo Clinic Proceedings: Digital Health, 1(3), 395–405. Note: Some of the authors work for the device manufacturer Moonbird. doi.org/10.1016/j.mcpdig.2023.06.008
- Fincham, G. W.; Strauss, C.; Montero-Marin, J.; Cavanagh, K. (2023). Effect of breathwork on stress and mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised-controlled trials. Scientific Reports, 13, 432. doi.org/10.1038/s41598-022-27247-y
- Goyal, M. et al. (2014). Meditation Programs for Psychological Stress and Well-being: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. JAMA Internal Medicine, 174(3), 357–368. doi.org/10.1001/jamainternmed.2013.13018
How we select and assess studies is explained on the overview page. Mjoll is a wellness app, not a medical device. Please read the safety notes.